Leadership and execution

Team autonomy: combining decision authority, trust and support

Giving a team room to learn without making every choice a manager's approval: authority by role and support adapted to the person and decision.

When I took over an operation that had experienced several consecutive loss-making years, fear of making mistakes was understandable. Many decisions, including pilots, moved up the hierarchy. If I approved everything, the operation would end up running at my pace.

The dilemma was concrete: if the team had to prove it could decide before gaining autonomy, where could it demonstrate that capability if every decision came back to the manager?

That is one version of the chicken-and-egg problem in management. Trust needs to develop through practice, and practice requires some room to decide.

Clear boundaries for decisions

We defined decision authority by role. Only exceptions moved to the next level. That established known boundaries for exercising autonomy.

Authority was the same for people in the same role. Support varied according to the person and the decision. This distinction let us develop capability without turning every choice into another authorization.

Changing the leader's response

When someone brought me a problem, I resisted the urge to immediately offer a solution and asked three questions:

  1. What is the problem?
  2. What are two possible solutions?
  3. Which would you choose, and why?

Answering took effort at first. Over time, fewer decisions reached me. When they did, they generally arrived with a team recommendation for discussion.

Support according to need

With someone still learning a particular decision, I discussed the criteria beforehand. With someone who already understood that work, feedback could follow afterward. This applied the idea of situational leadership to support while preserving decision authority by role.

In the daily meeting, we reviewed indicators and addressed operational deviations. In one-to-one meetings, we discussed choices needing a more sensitive conversation, without exposing the person to the group.

I sought to understand what had shaped the decision, which bias might have influenced it and what the person would do differently. Review was part of learning as well as a way of addressing the immediate decision.

Room to learn within bounded risk

We also encouraged pilots. Testing on a small scale helped limit the cost of mistakes and build experience before larger decisions.

In this case, the first step was giving the team room to decide within boundaries. Trust developed through everyday choices and follow-up.

For leaders trying to delegate more effectively, the case suggests a review: is it clear what the role can decide, what must be escalated and how the person will receive support to learn? The answer helps distinguish limited capability from limited opportunity to exercise it.

A personal account by Leandro Oliveira.

Leandro Oliveira

Executive with experience in B2B sales, marketing, services and operations. Shares lessons from his professional career across different sales rhythms and markets.

Ready to develop your commercial operation?

Let us discuss the decisions, processes and capabilities that need to evolve.

Contact ProduBiz